Contact Us

Visit us in Amherst on Park Avenue next to Ziggy's!

Lighthouse Insurance

187 Park Ave.

Amherst, Ohio  44001

(440) 984-3463




Friend us on


  Brian Mastellone
Principal/ Owner  

Brian is a 1991 graduate from Firelands High School. He married his wife, Debra, in 1992 and they have 4 children. After graduation, Brian served 5 years in the United States Navy with the Seabees- Naval Construction Battalion. In 1996, he received an honorable discharge from his military service, and immediately began his career in the insurance industry working for MetLife. He also spent approximately 4 years working for an independent agency in Parma, Ohio.

Brian made the decision in December of 2000 to move forward with the dream of starting his own agency. By January, 2001, Lighthouse Insurance Agency LLC was open for business.

Today, Lighthouse Insurance Agency LLC is a flourishing, full-service, independent agency. In 2017, Lighthouse Insurance Agency LLC was recognized as a leader in the insurance industry by earning the Senior Partner Plus designation from Grange Insurance. This designation is awarded to agencies excelling in key areas, including customer service and overall agency performance. Out of nearly 4,000 independent agencies that sell Grange’s auto, home, life and business insurance products, Lighthouse Insurance Agency LLC is one of just 73 agencies to receive this award.

Lighthouse Insurance Agency LLC provides peace of mind and protection to policyholders by advising, educating and serving them as their needs change throughout their lives. Brian’s strong commitment to his customers is the foundation of his business.

  Debra Mastellone
Life Specialist/ Marketing Manager
  Matthew Metzger
Licensed Agent
  Gayle Myhrman
Licensed Agent/ CSR/ Office Manager
    Donna Sebo
Licensed Agent/ CSR
     Jennifer Smith